I don't want to be rude here, but these were some of the thoughts that came to my mind as they seemed obvious to me.
- People write letters to be with the editor's column irrespective of what they write (Some columns don't make sense how much ever or however you try to interpret them, but that by itself is a separate story) so that they can see their names in the newspaper.
- People who have a good command over the language of English (unlike me) try their luck at things that they know little or don't know.
The Know-It-Alls sure don't do their research properly. They don't know what the deal is about. They don't know what has taken place. They don't know how long it has taken place. They don't know why this is being done.
It has to be noted that the entire negotiations was kept under wraps till the UPA government came into picture. Nuclear stuff being highly sensitive needs to be under the veil of secrecy. If you think you are the sole citizen of the country who cares about the Nation more than anyone other patriot, you are wrong.
Certain matters do not fall under the category of "Right of Information". Certain negotiations have to be conducted without the interference of the general public. When we have a very very less percentage of people's representatives who are politically educated, read "knows-what-they-are-supposed-to-do". Half of the crowd in the Parliament do not know what the hell is being talked about.
Given this situation, it does not make any sense to involve any of the non-strategic parties in the deal.
Everyone, it is a deal, means it is give and take. Can anyone of these people tell what is the give and what is the take? They don't know. I have read Strobe Talbot's book on the negotiations that took place between him and Jaswant Singh. I would suggest everyone to read the book before writing anything about the Nuclear deal.
You shouldn't just act smart by writing something that you don't know about, but should be smart enough too to actually know what you are writing. It still beats me. What were they thinking?